Seals can change the tone of their voice just like humans, study finds

Baby seals can change their tone just like humans! Pups adjust their voice based on the volume of sea noises, study finds

  • Researchers in the Netherlands played sounds of the sea to baby harbour seals
  • Nearly all of them lowered their tone of voice when played more intense sounds
  • ‘Vocal plasticity’ is a rare trait in mammals other than humans, the experts say

Baby seals can change their tone of voice in response to different sounds just like humans, a new study reveals.

Scientists in the Netherlands played sea noises to baby harbour seals (Phoca vitulina), which have a wide range around Northern Europe. 

Nearly all of the pups lowered the tone of their voice when they were played more intense soundscapes, the experts found. 

The findings suggest that seals have ‘vocal plasticity’, the ability to alter the tone of their voice, which is a rare trait in mammals beside humans, the experts say. 

Scroll down for video  

Pictured, an adorable harbour seal pup at the Seal Centre Pieterburen, in Pieterburen, the Netherlands. The species (Phoca vitulina) lowered tone of voice when they were played sounds of the sea


Pitch is the high or low frequency of a sound. When you sing, you create pitch because your vocal cords vibrate at a certain speed. 

For example, a foghorn emits a low frequency or pitch, whereas the sound your smoke detector emits is a high frequency or pitch. 

Tone refers to a musical or vocal sound with reference to its pitch, quality and strength. 

The study was conducted at the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics (MPI) in Nijmegen, the Netherlands, and published in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences.

According to senior author Andrea Ravignani at MPI, mammals other than seals would raise the tone of their voices as noise increased.

‘What seals did was lowering the pitch of their voices to escape the frequency range of noise, something that only animals with good control of their larynx – including humans but potentially excluding most mammals – can do,’ he told CNET.  

‘By looking at one of the few other mammals who may be capable of learning sounds, we can better understand how we, humans, acquire speech, and ultimately why we are such chatty animals.’ 

The team studied eight harbour seal pups aged one to three weeks old that were being held at the Dutch Sealcentre Pieterburen, a rehabilitation centre, before being released back into the wild. 

To investigate whether the pups could adapt their voices to noises in the environment, the team first recorded noises from the nearby Wadden Sea. 

For several days, the sea noises were then played back to the pups, in three degrees of loudness (varying from no sound to 65 decibel), but with a similar pitch to that of the seal pups’ calls. 

The team recorded the seal pups’ spontaneous calls to see if they change their tone of voice to adapt to the sea noises. 

Harbour seals, also known as common seals, live in temperate coastal habitats along the northern coasts of North America, Europe, and Asia

Interestingly, when the seal pups heard louder sea noises, they lowered their tone of voice, the team found. The pups also kept a more steady pitch with the more intense noise levels. 

The pups did not produce more or longer calls when they heard different levels of sea noise. 

There was an exception, however; one seal clearly produced louder calls when the noise got louder – something known as the Lombard effect. 

Harbour seals are less abundant in the UK than grey seals. Harbour seals have a dog-like face with large brown eyes, white whiskers and a snub nose


The Lombard effect makes people speak louder and more clearly in a noisy environment.

The Lombard effect is typical for human speech, as people raise their voices in noise to be better understood.

It’s an involuntary response speakers experience in the presence of noise during voice communication.  

Humans display the the Lombard effect too – we speak louder and more clearly in a noisy environment, just like a crowded bar or nightclub.   

The study suggests young seals adapt to the noises in their environment by lowering the tone of their voice, an ability they seem to share with humans and bats. 

Other animals in similar experiments only raise their voice (i.e. make louder calls) in response to louder noise.

‘Seal pups have a more advanced control over their vocalisations than assumed up until now,’ said Ravignani. 

‘This control seems to be already present at only few weeks of age. This is astonishing, as few other mammals seem capable of that. 

‘To date, humans seem to be the only mammals with direct neural connections between the cortex (the outer layer of the brain) and the larynx (what we use to produce tone of voice). 

‘These results show that seals may be the most promising species to find these direct connections, and unravel the mystery of speech.’

Seals are also capable of vocal learning – the ability to imitate sounds, just like a parrot does.   

This was previously demonstrated by Hoover, a harbour seal at New England Aquarium in Boston, Massachusetts in the 1970s and 1980s. 

George Swallow of Maine holds Hoover at the animal’s home at the New England Aquarium in Boston on August 16, 1971. Hoover was found in June that year by a Maine lobsterman when she was only a day or two old after her mother has been killed. Swallow and his wife took care of the seal and have found it a new home at the aquarium

Hoover the talking seal, discovered as a pup in 1971 by a Maine lobsterman, was able to mimic human speech. 

Hoover was initially kept in a family home and could bark catchphrases in a gruff New England accent, such as ‘come over here’ and ‘hello, there!’  

Harbour seals, also known as common seals, live in temperate coastal habitats along the northern coasts of North America, Europe, and Asia. 

In the UK, they can be seen around the coasts of Scotland, Northern Ireland and eastern England. 


Grey and harbour (or common) seals can be seen all year round largely on the coast of Scotland. 

To the untrained eye, telling the difference between a grey and a harbour seal can be quite difficult. 

When viewed in profile, grey seals have much flatter noses (‘a Roman nose’) than harbour seals, whose faces are more dished (they have relatively distinct foreheads). 

Grey seals’ eyes are located midway between the nose and the back of the head; harbour seals’ eyes (and mouths) are very much on the front of the face, closer to the nose. 

Unlike harbour seals, grey seals have double chins. In terms of the overall head shape, an oval drawn around a harbour seal’s head would need to be squashed from top to bottom while one drawn around a grey seal’s head would be squashed from side to side. 

Grey seals are the larger of the two species. Adult greys are around 5.9 to 6.8 feet long (1.8 to 2.1m), while adult harbour are 4.2 to 5.5 feet long (1.3 to 1.7m).

There are also differences in the coats pattern or ‘pelage’, of the two species.

Harbour seals are usually fairly uniformly spotted while grey seals have more obviously contrasting pale bellies and darker grey backs, with larger more irregularly shaped spots and blotches. 

Male grey seals have darker coats than females. But a seal’s pelage can look very different depending on whether it is wet or dry, and also when it is going through its annual moult (December to March for grey seals and July to September for harbour seals). 

Read more: Sea Mammal Research Unit – University of St Andrews 

Source: Read Full Article